Building Institutions - a path to racial and social integration for Muslims in the American Society
Institution - An established organization or corporation (as a bank or university) especially of a public character
Suddenly,
in fall of 2005 the Muslim community in the blue color city of
Birmingham found itself at odds with its non Muslim neighbors. This came
as a big surprise to many, as most of the Muslims living in this city
were 2nd or 3rd generation British born and raised. They paid taxes,
lived and worked next to there non Muslim neighbors and sent there
children to public schools. So why after living in a country and in a
community for decades did they find themselves alienated and targeted?
One can spend many hours debating over the evidence, but the one fact
remains, it happened, and It shouldn't have surprised us at all; as mere
residency in a society is not necessarily a sign of Cultural or Social
integration. I believe that in order for a sub community to fully
integrate itself; it must at least perceive to have a stake in the
overall process and the ability to influence it. The creation of local
institutions facilitates and helps communities organize in an
influential manner. These give the community a sense of ownership and
stake, allowing its members to participate and influence the overall
agenda. To be effective these institutions need to be diverse and
varied; spanning cultural, financial, religious and political
boundaries.
For the American Muslim community, the current
landscape is fairly bleak. There are very few world class Muslim
institutions, and the ones that do exist, provide the most fundamental
and rudimentary services to its constituents. The existing
infrastructure consists of mostly religious hubs such as Mosques and
Islamic schools; these are the first to mushroom in any new community
and help regulate the basic needs of its members, e.g. prayers,
marriages, religious education, funeral services etc. In all major US
metro areas these have flourished and service levels have improved over
time.
Over the last decade the Islamic education sector has seen
rapid growth, this is largely due to significant demand for quality
primary education by mostly professional and affluent Muslim parents.
Larger schools, focusing not just on primary but secondary and High
School education are also starting to appear at an accelerated pace
throughout major metropolitan suburbs. In principal these schools are
structured similar to the Catholic school system and focus on teaching
standard curriculum with additional focus on Islamic education. The
growing economic disparity between the urban lower middle class and
there fellow suburban dwelling professionals is alarming, and as a
result, the larger more established schools find themselves catering
mostly to the affluent Muslims; leaving the urban families with limited
options.
Although a few Muslim Universities and Colleges exist,
they are still very few and far apart. On this front, some geographic
areas have done better than others, for example the Chicagoland
community has made progress with the establishment and rapid growth of
East West University. An institution started over two decades ago now
boasting enrollment of close to 2000 students, mostly non Muslims.
Offering Liberal Arts and Engineering curriculum, East West University
is an excellent example of a simple idea turning into a local
institution, serving not only its original constituents, but a much
larger community by evolving into a seamless local institution. Even
with these sporadic successes a tremendous amount of work still needs to
be done on the education front in other locations and communities.
Living
in the United States it is difficult to go to a US city, town or
village without running into a Muslim doctor. Associations such as AAPNA
and others boast thousands of members, all Muslim doctors. Even with
these large numbers, it is hard to find a single reputable large medical
institution started or run by members of the Muslim medical community.
This situation is counter intuitive; with so many Muslim doctors
shouldn't we have an abundance of institutions? I believe in this
scenario the dilemma exists due to the lack of management expertise
amongst Muslim doctors. Doctors are arguably the most affluent Muslim
community in the US and have the opportunity to take a leadership role
in the institution building process. So far they have dropped the ball
on this front. Organizations such as AAPNA, with an established member
community and access to funds should prioritize efforts to help identify
and support candidates who can be developed into business leaders via
education and training.
For any community to flourish the
availability of capital for consumer and commercial purposes is
paramount; for this reason alone the lack of Islamic financial
institutions in the US is of significant concern; having institutions
that serve the special needs of the Muslim community by providing
Shariah compliant financial products and offerings is a necessary step
forward. Activities such as home buying and business investments
increase an individual's stake in the community, and this impact is
almost more important than all others; this in my opinion is the seed
that allows individuals to take an interest in there surrounding
environment and participate in the community at a heightened level.
Development of Islamic financial institutions would allow Muslims in
America to be on a path of integration and participation in the American
society. A tremendous amount of progress has taken place in the Islamic
finance arena and countries such as Malaysia, Bahrain, U.A.E and
Pakistan are at the forefront of this effort.
It is estimated that
there are between 4-7 Million Muslims living in the United States
(depending on whose numbers you believe), but unfortunately with the
exception of a few first efforts, Islamic finance is still in its
infancy. In order to avoid paying interest many successful Muslim
families don't participate in homeownership and other interest related
activities. The ones that forgo this hesitancy usually do so with
feelings of guilt. Over the last five years Guidance Financial has
started offering home mortgage products to the US Muslim community. The
effort has been met with a fair amount of success and is a good start,
but consumers will benefit from additional players entering the market.
Unfortunately,
on the commercial front, Shariah compliant lending institutions are no
where to be found. There are some local institutions such as Devon Bank
in Chicago and University Bank in Michigan that are starting to dabble
with commercial lending, but being small community banks they are
limited in there resources. Additionally, the absence of a Secondary
market to resell these loans as Mortgage Backed Securities (MBS)
threatens to choke any growth in this effort. The lack of a developed
Islamic secondary market forces many institutions to carry the loans for
the duration of the term, which creates a liquidity problem. Even
though some examples exist of portfolio sales to Freddie Mac and Fannie
Mae (Government funded Secondary markets for conventional/interest
baring loans), the development and creation of a more permanent
secondary market for Islamic/Shariah compliant loans is essential for
any future growth in the US. This one activity alone could breathe new
life into the Islamic financial markets and would most likely embolden
other institutions to accelerate product development efforts.
Islamic
finance is currently estimated to be a $400 Billion business worldwide,
and according to the UK-based Islamic Finance Information Service $16.9
billion in Islamic bonds (Sukuks), were issued in the first 10 months
of 2006 - 43 percent more than all Islamic bonds issued in 2005. The
success of Shariah compliant financing instruments in the UK serves to
strengthen and validate the market worldwide. For the US market the
creation of additional institutions and products is a necessity, Credit
Cards, Bonds (Sukuks) Auto financing, equipment and inventory financing
and construction loans are some of the areas that need development and
investment.
Middle East based Investment banks and Private Equity
companies have also started to open offices in the US, Arcapita (owners
of Church's Chicken and Caribou coffee chains), Kingdom Holdings and
Unicorn Investment Bank are examples of such companies. Some of these
institutions especially Kingdom Holdings has been involved in taking
positions and doing deals for over 10 years, but these overseas
companies do little to engage the local communities in the US and
therefore tend to have very little impact on the local landscape. Any
future dialogue leading to collaboration at the local level could
benefit both sides.
As the above mentioned examples illustrate,
some preliminary work is being done to build institutions by the Muslim
community, but unless the urgency is felt on a broader scale, these
efforts will continue to be "test cases" and "one off" scenarios. The
diverse Muslim community in the US is comprised of entrepreneurs from
all over the world and many of the community members are actively
involved via there jobs in helping others build and run the same kind of
institutions. There is certainly no lack of expertise; but I believe a
lack of inspiration and guidance; with community support and guidance
the Muslim intellectuals and entrepreneurs could certainly create world
class institutions, but only if they have the courage to dare.
That
is why the Muslim community in the U.S must learn to recognize there
superstars and engage actively and collectively to develop them into
leaders. As the events in Birmingham, England indicate, it is paramount
for the Muslim community in the US to avoid a similar fate, if they
succeed, they will redefine there role in history and if they fail,
history will surely define them.
As we sail through the year 2007
it is encouraging to see sparks of innovation and leadership all over
the country, and there is some hope for the future, but it is a bit
indulgent for the Muslim Americans to believe that there future
generations will be able to fulfill their dreams. I fear that if Muslim
professionals don't set examples now, and fail to create leadership
icons today, they will also fail to inspire the future generations.
A Chicago based Pakistani American writer.
No comments:
Post a Comment